UPDATES: November 2008

UPDATES is a monthly email newsletter on stormwater management, assessment (including monitoring), and maintenance research at St. Anthony Falls Laboratory and the University of Minnesota.

Click HERE to subscribe to UPDATES Newsletter

Or Text SWUPDATES to 22828 to Join. Message and data rates may apply.

For Email Marketing you can trust


November 2008 (vol. 3, issue 3)

Particle Size and Settling Velocity Distributions in Urban Stormwater Runoff

Contributed by Eric Hettler (Contact: John Gulliver)

Funded by: Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, Local Road Research Board, Mississippi Watershed Management Organization, and Minnehaha Creek Watershed District

The research team is currently working to apply simple, effective methods to characterize the particle size distribution and settling velocity distribution in urban stormwater runoff. Since many best management practices depend on settling velocity, a better understanding of the settling velocity distribution can lead to more efficient and more site-specific designs. An elutriation device developed by Walling and Woodward (1993) and Krishnappan and Marselek (2004) is being modified and tested to determine its effectiveness in measuring the settling velocity distribution of solids in stormwater. In the elutriation device, stormwater is pumped vertically through a column of a known diameter, and the upward velocity can be calculated for a given flow rate. Solids with a settling velocity greater than the upward velocity settle in the column while solids with a smaller settling velocity are flushed through the column. Initial experiments show the elutriation device can be effective in separating solids based on settling velocities. Work on the elutriation device and other potential solutions is ongoing.

Once a cheap, simple, and effective method to characterize settling velocity distribution is developed, the research team hopes to work with consultants and watershed districts to apply the methods in the field.

Impacts of Stormwater Infiltration on Groundwater

Contributed by Pete Weiss

Funded by Minnesota Pollution Control Agency

Infiltration of stormwater, which is being more widely used across the country, can increase groundwater recharge, reduce runoff peak flows and volumes, and reduce non-point source pollution. There has been, however, an increased concern in Minnesota that pollutants present in stormwater may contaminate groundwater. Thus, to understand the fate of infiltrated stormwater pollutants and better understand the risk of groundwater contamination, a literature review of scientific and engineering journals was undertaken.

The review found that risk of contamination by heavy metals, hydrocarbons, and phosphate are typically very low. Metals and hydrocarbons are usually removed in the first 20-50 cm of soil media or less and phosphate concentrations were found to be higher in groundwater than the infiltration water. The latter finding suggests that phosphates are leached from the soil into the infiltrating runoff. Bacteria and viruses were also found to be typically filtered by the infiltration media but under favorable conditions they can survive for extended periods of time and be mobile. Although the risk of groundwater contamination from the aforementioned contaminants is low, documented cases of contamination for each contaminant do exist so care and long-term planning are essential to the preservation of groundwater resources.

Karst areas and other areas where the subsurface has cracks and fissures can obviously increase the risk of groundwater contamination. Also, any system that utilizes subsurface injection increases the risk of groundwater contamination. Finally, salts are not removed by any infiltration systems and in some cold weather climates, salt concentrations of groundwater and area lakes has been documented to be increasing. This is presumably due to application of salt to roadways during the winter months. With all pollutants, the risks of infiltration versus other means of stormwater management must be carefully weighed and considered.


Poly Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHS) in Wet Pond Sediments

Contributed by Scott Kyser
John Gulliver or Ray Hozalski)

Funded by Minnesota Pollution Control Agency

High levels of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) have been found in many stormwater pond sediments in the Minneapolis/St. Paul metro area. Under MPCA regulations dredged sediments containing high levels of PAHs must be disposed of in a landfill which is prohibitively expensive for many municipalities. The potential to remediate PAH containing sediments through composting techniques is being investigated first using a proof-of-concept benchtop experiment and later an outdoor field size experiment. The goal of

the project is to design a composting procedure that effectively remediates PAH containing sediments to lower levels so that they can be disposed of more cost-effectively.

SAFL Research Updates

Assistant engineer Andrew Fyten, shown here monitoring an Environment21 stormwater management device, is one of many researchers working on issues of stormwater Best Management Practices (BMPs) at SAFL. Other recent activities include graduate student Dave Saddoris and researcher Omid Mohseni’s study of potential scouring resuspension and outwash of stormwater BMP devices. Mohseni is also working with the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) to provide the first industry standard for testing. For more about SAFL’s Stormwater BMP engineering services, please visit: www.safl.umn.edu/research/stormwaterBMPassessment.



  • Maintenance of Stormwater BMPs, by Joo-Hyon Kang, Peter T. Weiss, John S Gulliver, C. Bruce Wilson. Stormwater Magazine, Volume 9, Number 8, Nov/Dec 2008.
  • http://www.stormh2o.com/november-december-2008/issue-40172.aspx
  • Inventory of road salt uses in the Minneapolis/St. Paul metropolitan area, by Andrew Sander, Eric Novotny, Omid Mohseni, and Heinz Stefan. SAFL Project Report 503, December 2007.
  • http://home.safl.umn.edu/bmackay/pub/pr/pr503.pdf
  • Road salt effects on the water quality of lakes in the Twin Cities
  • metropolitan area, by Eric Novotny, Dan Murphy and Heinz Stefan. SAFL Project Report 505, Dec. 2007.
  • http://home.safl.umn.edu/bmackay/pub/pr/pr505.pdf

Citation: "Stormwater Research at St. Anthony Falls Laboratory." University of Minnesota, St. Anthony Falls Laboratory. Minneapolis, MN. http://stormwater.safl.umn.edu/